Energy consumption analysis and energy efficiency evaluation of iron-making system
DU Xueqiang1,2, LI Xiuping3, ZHOU Jicheng3, SHANGGUAN Fangqin3
1. Central Iron and Steel Research Institute Co., Ltd., Beijing 100081, China; 2. Automation Research and Design Institute of Metallurgical Industry, Beijing 100071, China; 3. Steel Industry Green and Intelligent Manufacturing Technology Center, China Iron and Steel Research Institute Group, Beijing 100081, China
Abstract:The energy conservation progress of steel industry in China has gone through several stages, such as single equipment energy conservation, system energy conservation and the popularization of major energy-saving technologies,to the current stage of energy flow network operation and improving energy conversion functions. The energy conservation of steel industry in China has made remarkable achievements. The energy conservation and emission reduction situation faced by the steel industry is becoming increasingly severe. In recent years, although the comprehensive energy consumption per ton of steel has still been reduced, the decrease has been very small, and even rebounded slightly in some years. Under the current theory and technologies, it is an obvious fact that the energy saving potential is decreasing, and it is very important to accurately determine the possibility and potential of energy saving. The pre-ironmaking system is the most significant energy consumption system of the steel manufactory process. Therefore, the pre-ironmaking system energy consumption is analyzed as an example, and the concepts of minimum energy consumption and standard energy consumption are proposed. Based on factory practice, the basis for determining ideal operating condition and standard operating condition, as well as the calculation method of theoretical minimum energy consumption and standard energy consumption are provided. The theoretical minimum energy consumption and standard energy consumption, as well as the actual energy consumption and standard energy consumption, are comparatively analyzed. Based on the analysis of the differences between ideal operating condition and standard operating condition, as well as between actual operating condition and standard operating condition, the ways and directions for energy saving for the coking process, sintering process, and iron-making process are provided respectively; Using the e-p analysis method under the theory of system energy saving, the influencing factors of the pre-ironmaking system, such as the system structure, the equipments scale, the raw material and fuel conditions, the energy-saving technology application, and the energy flow network are analyzed; and the measures and directions of energy conservation are proposed. The research results can provide theoretical support for the reasonable evaluation of the energy-saving potential of the pre-ironmaking system in the steel industry.
杜学强, 郦秀萍, 周继程, 上官方钦. 铁前系统能耗分析与评价[J]. 钢铁, 2023, 58(10): 163-171.
DU Xueqiang, LI Xiuping, ZHOU Jicheng, SHANGGUAN Fangqin. Energy consumption analysis and energy efficiency evaluation of iron-making system[J]. Iron and Steel, 2023, 58(10): 163-171.
[1] 上官方钦,张春霞,胡长庆,等.中国钢铁工业的 CO2排放估算[J].中国冶金,2010,20(5):37.(SHANGGUAN F Q, ZHANG C X, HU C Q,et al. Estimation of CO2 emission in Chinese steel industry[J]. China Metallurgy, 2010,20(5):37.) [2] 张春霞,上官方钦,胡长庆,等.钢铁流程结构及对 CO2排放的影响[J].钢铁,2010,45(5):1.(ZHANG C X,SHANGGUAN F Q,HU C Q,et al. Steel process structure and its impact on CO2 emission[J]. Iron and Steel,2010,45(5):1.) [3] 上官方钦,周继程,王海风,等. 气候变化与铁工业脱碳化发展[J]. 钢铁,2021,56(5):1. (SHANGGUAN F Q, ZHOU J C, WANG H F, et al. Climate change and decarbonization development of steel industry[J]. Iron and Steel, 2021,56(5):1.) [4] 张琦,田硕硕,沈佳林.中国钢铁行业碳达峰碳中和时间表与路线图[J].钢铁,2023,58(9):59.(ZHANG Q, TIAN S S,SHEN J L. Roadmap and timetable for achieving carbon peak and carbon neutrality of China's iron and steel industry[J]. Iron and Steel,2023,58(9):59.) [5] 郦秀萍,上官方钦,周继程,等. 钢铁制造流程中碳素流运行与碳减排途径[M]. 北京:冶金工业出版社,2020.(LI X P, SHANGGUAN F Q, ZHOU J C, et al. Carboniferous Flow Operation and CO2 Emission Reduction in Steel Manufacturing Process[M]. Beijing: Metallurgy Industry Press,2020.) [6] 杜学强,周继程,上官方钦,等.基于碳素流分析铁前系统CO2排放及减排措施[J].烧结球团,2022,47(1):247.(DU X Q, ZHOU J C,SHANGGUAN F Q, et al. CO2 emission and reduction measures of pre-iron system based on carbon flow analysis[J]. Sintering and Pelletizing, 2022,47(1):247.) [7] 张福明.炼铁系统低碳技术发展前景与途径[J].钢铁,2022,57(9):11.(ZHANG F M. Development prospects and methods on low-carbon technology in ironmaking system[J]. Iron and Steel,2022,57(9):11.) [8] 何坤,王立.中国钢铁工业生产能耗的发展与现状[J].中国冶金,2021,31(9):26.(HE K, WANG L. Development and status of production energy consumption of China's iron and steel industry[J]. China Metallurgy, 2021,31(9):26.) [9] 周继程,郦秀萍,上官方钦,等. 钢铁制造流程能源转换机制与能源利用效率分析[J]. 钢铁,2019,54(4):76.(ZHOU J C,LI X P,SHANGGUAN F Q, et al. Energy conversion mechanism and energy efficiency of steel manufacturing process[J]. Iron and Steel, 2019,54(4):76.) [10] 王海风, 平晓东,周继程 等. 中国钢铁工业绿色发展回顾及展望[J]. 钢铁,2023,58(2): 8.(WANG H F, PING X D, ZHOU J C, et al. Review and prospect of green development for Chinese steel industry[J]. Iron and Steel, 2023,58(2): 8.) [11] 张琦,蔡九菊. 钢铁制造流程系统节能与能效提升[J]. 钢铁,2021,56(8):32.(ZHANG Q,CAI J J. Energy saving and energy efficiency improvement of steel manufacturing process system[J]. Iron and Steel,2021,56 (8):32.) [12] 中国钢铁工业协会.中国钢铁工业统计月报[R].北京:中国钢铁工业协会,2022:10.(China Iron and Steel Association. China Iron and Steel Industry Monthly Statistics[R].Beijing:China Iron and Steel Association,2022:10.) [13] 上官方钦,刘正东,殷瑞钰.钢铁行业“碳达峰”“碳中和”实施路径研究[J].中国冶金,2021,31(9):15.(SHANGGUAN F Q, LIU Z D, YIN R Y. Study on implementation path of "carbon peak" and "carbon neutrality" in steel industry in China[J]. China Metallurgy, 2021,31(9):15.) [14] 蔡九菊, 孙文强. 中国钢铁工业的系统节能和科学用能[J]. 钢铁,2012,47(5): 1.(CAI J J,SUN W Q. Systems energy conservation and scientific energy utilization of iron and steel industry in China[J]. Iron and Steel,2012,47(5):1.) [15] 刘征建,王家保,张建良,等. 高炉能耗现状及降耗技术展望[J]. 钢铁研究学报,2023,35(1):1.(LIU Z J,WANG J B,ZHANG J L,et al. Current situation of energy consumption of blast furnace and prospect of consumption reduction technology[J]. Journal of Iron and Steel Research,2023,35 (1):1.) [16] 王新东,刘义,黄世平. 焦化能源流高效集成关键技术研发与应用[J]. 化工进展,2018,37(8):3260.(WANG X D,LIU Y,HUANG S P. Development and application of key technologies for efficient integration of coking energy flow[J]. Advances in Chemical Industry,2018,37 (8):3260.) [17] 胡兵,王兆才,李宗平,等. 烧结工序能耗精细化管理及其软件开发[J]. 中国冶金,2016,26(9):12.(HU B,WANG Z C,LI Z P,et al. Fine Management of energy consumption in Sintering process and its software development[J]. China Metallurgy,2016,26 (9):12.) [18] FRUEHAN R J,FORTINI O,PAXTON H W,et al. Theoretical Minimum Energies to Produce Steel for Selected Conditions[D]. PA: Carnegie Mellon University,2000. [19] 李士琦,钱刚,孙开明,等,电弧炉炼钢高效化的能耗状况分析[J].钢铁,2008,43(7):86.(LI S Q,QIAN G,SUN K M,et al. Energy consumption analysis for high efficiency of electric arc furnace steelmaking[J].Iron and Steel,2008,43 (7):86.) [20] 朱荣,任鑫,薛波涛. 转炉炼钢工艺极限碳排放研究进展[J]. 钢铁,2023,58(3):1.(ZHU R,REN X,XUE B T. Research progress of limiting carbon emission in converter steelmaking process[J]. Iron and Steel,2023,58 (3):1.) [21] 张春霞,胡长庆,严定鎏,等. 温室气体和钢铁工业减排措施,中国冶金,2007,17(1):7.(ZHANG C X,HU C Q, YAN D L, et al. GHG emission and its mitigation of steel industry[J].China Metallurgy, 2007,17(1):7.) [22] 彭岩,曹先常,张玉柱.钢铁典型工序流程节能技术新进展[J].中国冶金,2017,27(5):8. (PENG Y, CAO X C, ZHANG Y Z. New progresses of energy saving solutions in typical iron and steel making process flow[J]. China Metallurgy, 2017,27(5):8.) [23] 苍大强. 钢铁工业“碳达峰”“碳中和”及低碳技术的误区及实现路径[J]. 中国冶金,2021,31(9):3.(CANG D Q. Misunderstandings and realistic path of "carbon peak" "carbon neutrality" and low carbon technologies in iron and steel industry[J]. China Metallurgy, 2021,31(9):3.) [24] 郦秀萍,蔡九菊,殷瑞钰,等. 转炉炼钢工序最小能耗的研究[J].钢铁,2003,38(5):50.(LI X P, CAI J J, YIN R Y, et al. Study on minimum energy consumption of converter procedure[J]. Iron and Steel, 2003,38(5):50.) [25] 郦秀萍,蔡九菊,王鼎,等.转炉工序能耗分析与评价,冶金能源,2004,23(2):7.(LI X P, CAI J J, WANG D, et al. Analysis and assessment for energy consumption of converter procedure[J]. Energy for Metallurgy Industry, 2004,23(2):7.) [26] 郦秀萍.高炉-转炉区段工艺技术界面热能工程分析[D].沈阳:东北大学,2005.(LI X P. Thermal Engineering Analysis for the Techno-Interface of BF-BOF Region[D].Shenyang: Northeastern University,2005.) [27] 周继程. 钢铁制造流程能量流网络构建与案例研究[D]. 北京: 钢铁研究总院,2014.(ZHOU J C. Construction and Case Study on Energy Flow Network of Steel Manufacturing Process[D]. Beijing: Central Iron and Steel Research Institute, 2014.) [28] 刘文超. 我国钢铁工业能耗剖析及最小能耗研究[D]. 沈阳:东北大学,2013. (LIU W C. Research on Energy Consumption and its Minimization for Chinese Iron and Steel Industry [D]. Shenyang: Northeastern University, 2013) [29] 杜学强,郦秀萍. 铁前区段铁素物流变化对能耗的影响[C]//中国自动化大会论文集.上海:中国自动化学会,2020:861.(DU X Q, LI X P. The influence of Fe-material flow on energy consumption of pre-iron making section[C]//Proceeding of China Automation Congress. Shanghai:China Automation Congress, 2020:861.) [30] LI X P,FAN B,XU H C, et al. Study of the influence of ferruginous matter flow change on energy consumption of iron-making section[C]//Asia Steel 2009. Busan:The Korean Institute of Metals and Materials, 2009. [31] 殷瑞钰.冶金流程集成理论与方法[M]. 北京:冶金工业出版社,2013.(YIN R Y. Theory and Method of Metallurgical Process Integration[M]. Beijing: Metallurgy Industry Press,2013.) [32] 王维兴. 高炉炼铁对炉料的质量要求[C]//第十四届全国炼铁原料学术会议. 兰州:中国金属学会,2015:1.(WANG W X. Requirements for blast furnace burden quality[C]//14th Academic Conference of Iron-making Burden. Lanzhou: The Chinese Society for Metals,2015:1.)